Mr. Welch
Mr. Welch
  • Видео 584
  • Просмотров 2 221 930
The Unholy Trinity of RPGs
I have talked about the best of the best when it comes to RPGs, but these three are the worst of the worst. For your watching endurement, please tolerate these examples of how not to make a game. Featuring:
World of Synnabar, the RPG of excessive settings and rules
Phoenix Command, the RPG of excessive math. Also the only one that has nothing actually wrong with the contents of the book.
FATAL, the RPG that should have never been written. Despite RUclips saying there is nothing wrong with this section, don't watch it with kids in the room.
Просмотров: 3 056

Видео

World of Darkness Compilation
Просмотров 2 тыс.15 часов назад
Come viewers, let us go back to the grimdark darkness of the grimdark 90's, when RPG discovered they could cover mature topics and still make money. White Wolf made gaming history with the World of Darkness, with the primary releases of Vampire, Werewolf, Mage, Wraith and Changeling. These games changed all the rules, spawned tv shows and video games, and created a culture in the RPG industry t...
Welcome to Mystara: The Complete Line of Basic Modules
Просмотров 4 тыс.22 часа назад
Fulfilling another request, compiling all the modules from the Basic line of the BECMI editions. Starting with B1 In Search of the Unknown all the way to B12 Queen's Harvest. Two hours of some of the most well known and classic modules D&D ever made, as well as a few of the most expensive. 00:00 In Search of the Unknown 07:08 Keep on the Borderlands 18:26 Palace of the Silver Princess 33:13 The...
Welcome to Mystara: Gazetteer Compilation
Просмотров 4,1 тыс.День назад
As everyone knows, the greatest setting ever created for D&D was Mystara. It broke from the industry standard of a single boxed set by introducing each nation individually. Instead of a few paragraphs detailing each nation, you got dozens of pages for each nation in a series called the Gazetteers that gave you everything you needed to run full campaigns in just a single country. Now you can wat...
Welcome to Mystara: Valley of Wolves
Просмотров 1,2 тыс.День назад
Time to head to Northern Glantri to pet the doggos, as we are headed to Barony du Morlais, better known as the Valley of Wolves. This region is the only domain not only open to werewolves, but welcoming. Fully half the population are members of the changing breed, and it causes a lot of unique problems for the barony. Can this region survive once it gets elevated to a principality? Watch and fi...
12 Things 5E D&D Got Wrong...And How to Fix Them
Просмотров 5 тыс.14 дней назад
As Fifther Edition, the Fifthest of all editions, is right around the corner, time to take a look back to see what the hell happened with 5th edition. It came into the world with everybody praising it and tossing aside 4th like it was spoiled food. But then the crowds began to turn, people jumped to other systems and the grumbling increased. A chunk of this can be blamed on WOTC's numerous blun...
Welcome to Mystara: The High Heroes
Просмотров 2,3 тыс.14 дней назад
Most D&D races need a bunch of deities for their pantheons. Not the hin. The halflings of Mystara only need three, the forward-thinking Brinderhin, the wise Coberham Shadowglint, and the adventurous Nob Nar. This trio of Immortals represent everything the hin aspire to be, and in return watch over their kin and guide them to even greater achievements. And for people looking for something read, ...
Welcome to Mystara: Top 10 Blood Feuds
Просмотров 1,7 тыс.21 день назад
Sometimes, a spat is more than a spat. Sometimes it can only be solved with blood. And there's a lot of feuds in Mystara that have gone on for longer than any can remember, with a body count higher than anyone can figure. Even when the participants are restricted from actual combat, they still find a way to strike at each other. Here are ten of the oldest, bloodiest and bitterest grudges in all...
Welcome to Mystara: The Aesir
Просмотров 1,9 тыс.Месяц назад
Mystara's Immortals have a lot of lore and history behind them. None more frustrating than the Immortals given in the Northern Reaches Gazetteer and it makes us explain why the Northern Gods are suddenly deities in a game without gods. This has confounded many a DM, but fortunately through numerous sources and a lot of plot spackling we have an answer of why Odin and Hel are gods and Immortals,...
Welcome to Mystara: War Rafts of Kron
Просмотров 1,5 тыс.Месяц назад
Take equal parts great ideas and disjointed adventure design and throw them overboard, and you get War Rafts of Kron. This nautical adventure takes the party from a floating city to an underwater city to an underwater death trap dungeon, trying to rescue a princess who isn't even named in the module. You have to read the back cover to discover her name. Still, it's got a lot of great characters...
Welcome to Mystara: Kingdom of Minaea
Просмотров 1,6 тыс.Месяц назад
Time to head to the Vaults of Pandius for a look at a highly underdeveloped nation mentioned only on a map as a land of pirates. That was clearly fantasy Minoa. Fortunately we have a rabid fan base that will not let areas go undefined, so we actually now have information on the Confederation of City-States ruled by a king. And I get to introduce you it to you.
Welcome to Mystara: The Life of Moglai Khan
Просмотров 1,3 тыс.Месяц назад
Mystara is the setting of real-world analogies, so it makes sense for fantasy Mongolia to have fantasy Genghis Khan. Enter Moglai Khan, the Golden Khan, the man destined to conquer large parts of the Known World. He is a natural leader with devout followers, a well-trained army, and a legion of dwarves. But can he avoid the perils of unfortunate starting position, treacherous underlings, and wo...
Mr. Welch's Whirlwind Review of Rogue Trader Hurricane Special
Просмотров 2,3 тыс.Месяц назад
it's been a week since the hurricane I'm still without power, and I'm going stir crazy. so why not just do a flash review of the entire line of Rogue Trader books to pass the time. if anybody would like to help pay for chainsaw fuel here's where to send gasoline or the monetary equivalent. paypal.me/TheHGW
Stranger Ranger Danger: Fixing the D&D Ranger Class
Просмотров 4,9 тыс.2 месяца назад
It's a new edition, that means it's time to complain about the ranger again. For the sixth time. You know the class, limited combat options, stuck to specific terrain types, only good with a few weapons, lousy armor class, second best at everything they are supposed to be good at. The class has held on to class features that did them no justice, needlessly giving them useless spells or saddling...
Improving Your D&D Game With Sea Monsters And/Or Delicious Cajun Snacks
Просмотров 4,1 тыс.2 месяца назад
Improving Your D&D Game With Sea Monsters And/Or Delicious Cajun Snacks
Welcome to Mystara: Our Culturally Appropriating Orcs
Просмотров 8 тыс.2 месяца назад
Welcome to Mystara: Our Culturally Appropriating Orcs
Welcome to Mystara: Creating Your Own Magical Spells
Просмотров 1,7 тыс.2 месяца назад
Welcome to Mystara: Creating Your Own Magical Spells
What's Your Favorite D&D Adventure Style? (Featuring 12 classic adventures)
Просмотров 4,4 тыс.2 месяца назад
What's Your Favorite D&D Adventure Style? (Featuring 12 classic adventures)
Welcome to Mystara: The Birds
Просмотров 1,5 тыс.2 месяца назад
Welcome to Mystara: The Birds
Welcome to Mystara: Church of Thyatis
Просмотров 2 тыс.3 месяца назад
Welcome to Mystara: Church of Thyatis
Welcome to Mystara: Dueling in the Savage Coast
Просмотров 1,6 тыс.3 месяца назад
Welcome to Mystara: Dueling in the Savage Coast
The Part of the Vecna Video I'm Really Proud of but YT Didn't Like So Demonitized Me
Просмотров 2,4 тыс.3 месяца назад
The Part of the Vecna Video I'm Really Proud of but YT Didn't Like So Demonitized Me
Welcome to Mystara: Making Vecna Eve of Ruin Epic With Awesomeness Editors
Просмотров 7 тыс.3 месяца назад
Welcome to Mystara: Making Vecna Eve of Ruin Epic With Awesomeness Editors
Welcome to Mystara: Champions of Mystara
Просмотров 2,3 тыс.4 месяца назад
Welcome to Mystara: Champions of Mystara
Welcome to Mystara: Jaime Honey Creeper Ahua- Your Favorite All Powerful Undead? Cemetery Keeper
Просмотров 1,5 тыс.4 месяца назад
Welcome to Mystara: Jaime Honey Creeper Ahua- Your Favorite All Powerful Undead? Cemetery Keeper
Happy 50th Birthday D&D from 50 D&D Channels
Просмотров 3,5 тыс.4 месяца назад
Happy 50th Birthday D&D from 50 D&D Channels
Welcome to Mystara: The Kingdom of Eadrin
Просмотров 2,2 тыс.4 месяца назад
Welcome to Mystara: The Kingdom of Eadrin
Return of the King of the Britons
Просмотров 1,5 тыс.4 месяца назад
Return of the King of the Britons
Welcome to Mystara: The Nation of Sind
Просмотров 2,6 тыс.4 месяца назад
Welcome to Mystara: The Nation of Sind
Welcome to Mystara: Ee'ar the Winged Elves
Просмотров 1,3 тыс.4 месяца назад
Welcome to Mystara: Ee'ar the Winged Elves

Комментарии

  • @colinmerritt7645
    @colinmerritt7645 16 часов назад

    If we hear about a dark vortex opening up in Texas, we know what happened.

  • @Netjerenbau3000
    @Netjerenbau3000 16 часов назад

    I used to have Mummy. I didn't get how you were supposed to run it. Yes there were powers so that you could interact with Wraith stuff but they weren't universal and it was entirely probable that half of your players couldn't see the other half.

  • @mikej2239
    @mikej2239 16 часов назад

    This must have been tough to do, I thank you and hope that this small token can get you some eye bleach and back to the work or Mystara.

    • @Mr_Welch
      @Mr_Welch 15 часов назад

      Still have a half written script for the next remaster. Now that I'm not sick trying to finish it

  • @bobbailey4849
    @bobbailey4849 18 часов назад

    Sorry you put yourself through this, but thank you for jumping on that grenade for us. Thank the Immortals for Winona! Did you say flying bears with frickin' laser beams? but seriously, thank you for all your videos.

  • @ConcreteShaman
    @ConcreteShaman 21 час назад

    These RPG's have to be some kind of in-joke that was published. Theres no-way any mortal man would willingly play any of these games.

  • @szarkel
    @szarkel 21 час назад

    Ilsotthe how to play booklet anybody know where I can get a PDF of it?

  • @autisticallyaccurate
    @autisticallyaccurate 23 часа назад

    I would like to believe Fatal was made by Federal Agents to survey people who would be interested to buy and play it so that it may be easier to target and investigate them before arresting them. But it is probably as you have said, just an all round incorrigible fetish to be shared by and to ilk for deranged amusement.

  • @derekburge5294
    @derekburge5294 23 часа назад

    1d4X100 damage dagger. Yeah, okay.

  • @thekaxmax
    @thekaxmax День назад

    I got in the Discord for the dev for 'World of Synnabar' for the rerelease. I got out because the dev wanted to double down on almost everything people had problems with rather than fix them. He was also a conspiracy theorist of the first water, and a rude bastard if you didn't agree with every word he said.

  • @boobio1
    @boobio1 День назад

    For a much less hysterical review of FATAL: ruclips.net/video/caBfNrjFlQI/видео.html&t

  • @patrickholt2270
    @patrickholt2270 День назад

    I'm beginning to suspect that World of Synnabar is the product of a Vogon prose-poet. And it (Synnabar itself, the world ship within the RPG) would benefit from a scheduled visitation from a Vogon Constructor Fleet to turn it into a Hyperspace Bypass.

  • @chainsawsubtlety9828
    @chainsawsubtlety9828 День назад

    FATAL. Any person with a shred of decency thinks that it was written (poorly) by a psychopath, for degenerates. RUclips, however, has no problem with it, at all. Just something to keep in mind when you see a "Blue Context Box".

  • @z3r0_35
    @z3r0_35 День назад

    Phoenix Command sounds more like a system for a turn-based tactical combat video game rather than a tabletop game. If you have a computer doing all these calculations for you on the fly, it could make for a really cool game, but otherwise? Forget it.

    • @thekaxmax
      @thekaxmax День назад

      it's not a game, it's the combat system for a set of games.

    • @z3r0_35
      @z3r0_35 13 часов назад

      @@thekaxmax That's my point, it could be a GOOD combat system for a video game because all the calculations are done for you by a computer, but not a TTRPG.

  • @PhaedrusAK
    @PhaedrusAK День назад

    As stated in the review - Phoenix Command isn't an RPG. It started as the combat system for a couple of RPGs (and for serveral more in its basic version), but it's definitely a set of Skirmish Wargame rules - the front of the book calls it a 'Small Arms Combat System'. A couple of points in its favor... the basic version isn't bad in terms of difficulty, is short, and doesn't play slower than quite a lot of RPGs when using their advanced rules... and also, the actual hit location and damage rules are surprisingly simple and quick to use, and since they work on base 3d6 stats and swords do 1d8 you can slot them into a lot of other RPGs, which is a great way to teach players who complain about a lack of realism.

  • @boobio1
    @boobio1 День назад

    WHAT THE FUCK AM I LISTENING TO???

  • @RoninCatholic
    @RoninCatholic День назад

    I'm trying to make my own fantasy RPG, which when I describe it is either "GURPS with so many houserules it's basically D&D" or "D&D with so many houserules it's basically GURPS". Still going back and forth with myself if basic ability checks (which in turn are the basis of the skill, magic, and combat systems) should be roll-under with modifiers to the target number, or roll-over with difficulty set BY target number. One is more intuitive to me for bookkeeping, the other more intuitive in the moment to moment play as a player. Why should such a system even exist? Because the main character I project as my online persona is clearly bound by some sort of Tabletop RPG system, but no existing ruleset fits his world perfectly. Because most of my videogame development projects are confined to a small list of interconnected fantasy worlds and their histories with a shared set of magic systems, and one of those is the world he's from. Because I'm addicted to worldbuilding and lore and flavor text and find both that and crunchy game stats with hard numbers and randomization mechanics innately fun for their own sake.

  • @whiskeyhound
    @whiskeyhound День назад

    Good lord, that Cinnabar book opening crawl is so pointlessly 1950s-60s sci-fi it hurts. I don't get why the writer didn't space it out over the entire book.

    • @thekaxmax
      @thekaxmax День назад

      cos he's like that.

    • @whiskeyhound
      @whiskeyhound День назад

      @@thekaxmax I mean sure that explains it, but it still baffles me that despite seemingly lifting d&d mechanics wholesale, he'd never read a setting book to see that they don't need to beat you over the head with the entire backstory immediately. Like the Forgotten Realms original book where it's about 1/4 of the length of text and just describes the setting as of the present time on a single page.

  • @matthewconstantine5015
    @matthewconstantine5015 День назад

    What the Scientology is this nonsense? I actually remember when World of Siynnabar (1993) hit the shelves at the book store I worked at. I skimmed it a couple times, but couldn't make heads nor tails of it. If memory serves, we were the victim of a snatch & grab, and someone stole the books along with other stuff. We were insured, so it probably worked out for the best.

    • @thekaxmax
      @thekaxmax День назад

      I got in the Discord for the dev for 'World of Synnabar' for the rerelease. I got out because the dev wanted to double down on almost everything people had problems with rather than fix them. He was also a conspiracy theorist of the first water, and a rude bastard if you didn't agree with every word he said.

  • @GojiKaichou
    @GojiKaichou День назад

    Okay, World of Cinnabar.... how bad can this be? (14 minutes that feel like an eternity later...) HOLY FUCKNUGGETS, WHAT THE HELL IS THIS QUASI-RELIGIOUS HOLLOW EARTH THEORY BULLSHIT?? I feel for ya, having to read this. I'd have a stroke just trying to parse this mess.

  • @megarural3000
    @megarural3000 День назад

    At least Synnibar and Phoenix Command were trying to be games, FATAL, holy shit. I mean... holy shit.

  • @chadlynch1551
    @chadlynch1551 День назад

    What, no HōL? Human Occupied Landfill isn't nearly as bad as Cinnabar, but it's more goofy and fun.

    • @megarural3000
      @megarural3000 День назад

      HōL was impressively bad, but it was a parody work from the start, very much like the drug themed mini game included in the main book or Buttery HōLsomeness, I forget the title, but it was a parody packed inside a parody. Shout out for knowing of the existence of HōL.

  • @autisticallyaccurate
    @autisticallyaccurate День назад

    29:22 I adore your love for Winona. I love her still too.

  • @autisticallyaccurate
    @autisticallyaccurate День назад

    26:57 These bear seem amusing.

  • @autisticallyaccurate
    @autisticallyaccurate День назад

    Seems Gonzo to me, in a Discworld John Carter From Mars style.

    • @thekaxmax
      @thekaxmax День назад

      with a /really/ horrible system attached.

  • @havock89
    @havock89 День назад

    Sorry I got ten mins in, and I felt my brains dripping out of my ears...

  • @manubour
    @manubour День назад

    if you want to talk some of the worst RPGs, you might want to, or rather you might NOT want to talk about RaHoWa...

    • @Mr_Welch
      @Mr_Welch День назад

      @@manubour I would also really like to keep my channel

    • @manubour
      @manubour День назад

      @@Mr_Welch yeah, that one wouldn't get past yt's algorythm

    • @ghostpasha9076
      @ghostpasha9076 День назад

      RaHoWa doesn't count because it was never finished. At least they *finished* FATAL!

  • @douglasnelson4592
    @douglasnelson4592 День назад

    What horrible hell is this?

  • @chadlynch1551
    @chadlynch1551 День назад

    Why, why do you hate us so much?

  • @Mikethemerciless11
    @Mikethemerciless11 День назад

    I don't know if you've ever played Legend of the Five Rings RPG, but you ought to review that. It's one of the deadliest RPGs I've ever played, and that's coming from someone who loves Traveller.

  • @TheAutistWhisperer
    @TheAutistWhisperer День назад

    I want to get into the World of Darkness tabletop RPG, I really enjoyed the game Bloodlines.

  • @jacobhope6164
    @jacobhope6164 День назад

    Master Blaster runs Harbor Town!

  • @TheGenericavatar
    @TheGenericavatar День назад

    Synnabar - so awful and bad it's both funny in its absurdity while it inflicts massive psychic damage. Mr Welch, I'm surprised you didn't shatter and become a RL DC style Joker while reviewing that book. You must have been surrounded by Winona Ryder posters while doing the research and production of the Synabbar review video.

  • @CanuckWolfman
    @CanuckWolfman День назад

    I wonder how well Phoenix Command would work as a turn-based tactics computer game

  • @harleysmith6333
    @harleysmith6333 День назад

    I was like ooh look a new Mr Welch video and about 10 minutes in i stated outloud, What the hell am I listening too. Wow Cinnabar sounds awful jesus lmao

  • @DwarfElvishDiplomacy
    @DwarfElvishDiplomacy День назад

    Pheonix command could be interesting to press into a PC game because you dont need to look up the tables and do the roles

  • @sordcooper2
    @sordcooper2 День назад

    ...I'm 5 minuets into this rambling tale of epic bullshit and I want throttle the writer for the insane amount of erroneous nonsense they've worked in to get yo the set up of the premise alone We don't need to know the homeworld of the god that made another god who made the setting if none of that is going to show up anywhere near the game! Fuck, it's even vague in its over detailed description! Oh, all the true gods are tired and locked away because of a space war and that's caused a stellar storm that'll destroy the earth! Ok but why though? No answer, just some scientists who somehow chart the storms path and send earth a heads up about it... which we somehow understand Edit: EVIL INSTAND ADULT DEVIL BABY DESTROYS MANKIND ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME!? You set up gods dad's homeworlds childhood bedroom, and you don't explain shit about the demon baby that's the whole reason you have a lost in space world ship thing?! I know I'm just shouting to the void here but good god was this dictated to a stoner by a guy on an acid trip?!

  • @georgekharati2882
    @georgekharati2882 День назад

    I don't know what's more impressive, the fact that the publishers of Sinibar thought they could ban GMs from changing the rules or them being unhinged enough to think they could enforce this nonsense to begin with.

    • @thekaxmax
      @thekaxmax День назад

      I was in the support Discord group for the dev's rerelease of the game. Yeah, he's exactly like that. And 'he', not 'them'.

  • @midnightgreen8319
    @midnightgreen8319 День назад

    Mr Welch I'm interested to hear your thoughts on Dungeon Crawl Classics. It's my favorite Fantasy RPG, I love it.

    • @Mr_Welch
      @Mr_Welch День назад

      @@midnightgreen8319 I've actually done a review on it

  • @pointmanfrosty7206
    @pointmanfrosty7206 День назад

    You are a bad bad man do you know how many brain cells I had to kill to make the memory of this thing go away the first time . I’m 10 minutes in and my brain hurts

  • @saulschimek7680
    @saulschimek7680 День назад

    Ahhhh yes....World of Synnabar. A game claimed to be RIFTS on Aggressive Steroids but even less coherence. We have Dismissed Those Claims

  • @MrFleem
    @MrFleem День назад

    Oh no

  • @Scotsmind
    @Scotsmind День назад

    … what the

  • @orionrising8236
    @orionrising8236 День назад

    Wow...I feel like the Synnibar back story is going to go on for 26,000 years.

  • @jacobhope6164
    @jacobhope6164 День назад

    So, in The 13th Warrior, Antonio Banderas plays a Ylari.

  • @jamess3395
    @jamess3395 День назад

    This reminds me of DIO's Magica Story Edit: Speaking of course of the cinnabar part

    • @shallendor
      @shallendor День назад

      There is Holy Diver the Dio RPG v2

    • @thekaxmax
      @thekaxmax День назад

      Dio's is way better written and realised

  • @DonzaDJN
    @DonzaDJN День назад

    OK, so now what's the Holy Trinity of RPG's?

    • @rosskwolfe
      @rosskwolfe День назад

      Define what should qualify? Biggest/most popular? Best ruleset? Something else?

    • @davidfitzsimmons2451
      @davidfitzsimmons2451 День назад

      In terms of longevity, iconicness, and being different from each other... DnD, WoD, and Cyberpunk 2020. For all the flaws each one may possess, they are each respected and acknowledged as the prime example for each type of game and setting they provide.

    • @macoppy6571
      @macoppy6571 День назад

      1. Fatal 2. Cinnabar 3. Phoenix Command But few care to know.

    • @DonzaDJN
      @DonzaDJN День назад

      @@rosskwolfe Most likely the inverse of this video, but I'll leave that to Mr.Welch~

    • @DonzaDJN
      @DonzaDJN День назад

      @davidfitzsimmons2451 probably not D&D, it's oversaturated nowadays. But I'm not the C3, so I can't say~

  • @NotoriusBEN1
    @NotoriusBEN1 День назад

    This sounds like an elementary student's english homework. Mr Welch, why would you force your friend to record this? That is not very friend like...

  • @johnstuartkeller5244
    @johnstuartkeller5244 День назад

    Ah, the classics! My first encounter with WoD. Sophomore year of high-school, in a mythology class (that got cancelled during the second semester.) It was Werewolf, and my first thought was like Hammer and Universal monsters, more about the individual. Then tribes were thrown at me. I was into Led Zep at the time, so I was drawn to Fianna, though later I found preference for Shadow Lords. Funny thing is, I usually knew people who wanted to play Vampire instead of Werewolf, so I only got to play Werewolf twice. Side note: I know the Highlander supliment was fan-made, bit is there any chance you'll go over it, if only to discuss why or why not it works in WoD?

  • @TheZaiakusin
    @TheZaiakusin 2 дня назад

    Listening to this... Mummy and Wraith have a fair amount of overlap with Geist. Guess if I didn't latch onto Geist, one of those would be where I would have ended up in WoD.